Hairloss Headlines, Men's

Let Your Advertising Fight For You

Let Your Advertising Fight For You

By Steven DiManni

There is no other business in America that is more maligned, unfairly criticized and falsely stereotyped than the men’s hair replacement business. Not even the used car business is as frequently, and more inaccurately, attacked than ours.

The other night I was at home watching a late-night silent movie on TV. In the movie, a man is standing at a bus stop when a sudden wind blows the hair off his head and onto the face of the woman standing next to him. So, what does this tell me? That the negativity about hair replacement started at least FOUR generations ago. That’s some big stereotype we’re fighting, isn’t it?

Of course, you don’t need to watch old silent films to hear jokes about hair replacement. Remember a few years ago when every late-night talk show host was making jokes about Sy Sperling of Hair Club fame. Or how about when Bud Light and Geico both did unflattering parodies of traditional men’s hair replacement commercials?

And it’s not just movies and TV shows that disparage our industry. Even our brethren in the hair transplant industry take shots at non-surgical hair replacement. One huge hair transplant company frequently shows hair taken right out of the box, with the underside of the base as the focal point, as it compares its transplant procedures with “hair systems.” Is it any wonder that most men losing their hair resist even the thought of non-surgical processes?

What can we do?

In this case, it’s Michigan Avenue rather than Madison Avenue that has the answer. Chicago’s largest agency and one of the biggest in the world, Leo Burnett, created Tony the Tiger, the Friendly Skies of United, the Jolly Green Giant, the Marlboro Cowboy, even Charlie the Tuna. Its founder, Leo Burnett, claimed that an advertiser has to “show the inherent drama” of his product.

Now what does THAT mean? Well, Leo was using “adspeak” to simply say that at its core every product has something different about it, something that is dramatic and impressive to consumers. And what the advertiser needs to do is to “unlock” that special feature by showing it in a dramatic way.

Look at diamonds

“A diamond is forever.” Yes, it is, and now any woman who gets an engagement ring that’s anything but a diamond is looked at with pity. DeBeers (the South African mining co-op) equated diamonds, which last forever, with love. A diamond ring means the marriage will last forever, according to the message of DeBeers commercials. They made that the inherent drama of the product. And now they’re using it to sell the “eternity ring”, the “I’d marry you all over again ring”, and perhaps soon, “the ring-a-ding-ding-ring”. That’s how powerful showing the inherent drama of a product can be.

Are you familiar with the phrase, “Colgate toothpaste with MFP”? Most people are. Crest toothpaste was the first to include fluoride protection in its formula. They had commercials featuring “the Crest kids”–children who had used Crest over the years and had fewer cavities than kids who didn’t. So, what was Colgate to do when it introduced its own version of fluoridated toothpaste?

Colgate decided to make its fluoridated toothpaste sound even better than Crest. But how to do that when the two are exactly the same? Make up a name for its fluoride, of course. “MFP” stands for multiple fluoride protection. Did Crest also offer multiple fluoride protection? Sure, it did. But Colgate was the one that said it, and Colgate’s sales shot through the roof. Was Colgate saying something that was untrue? No, Colgate was just presenting its product in a more clever way than Crest did. That’s called marketing. And just like love and war, all is fair in marketing as long as it’s true.

Remember the Miller Lite ads from years back? They could have just been commercials that said that Miller Lite kind of tastes lighter than regular Miller and has fewer calories. But that would have been tantamount to admitting that Miller Lite was just watered down beer. So instead, Miller Lite used ex-athletes to shout “Less filling/Tastes great” at each other. That was the inherent drama of the product. And sales went through the roof.

What does it all mean?

So, what does that have to do with us? It’s a roadmap for countering consumer perceptions by showing the inherent drama of our product. Now to some extent, many in the industry already have. Showing extreme close-ups of the hair and scalp, running the comb through the hair, and so on, are all showing the inherent drama of the product. Why is that?

Because the one thing men don’t want is to wear something on top of their heads. Showing hair and scalp with a comb running through it gives these men permission to believe that this is not something that goes over their head.

There’s nothing wrong or misleading with this. It happens to be true. If you run a comb through someone’s hair, all you see IS hair and scalp. So why not tell the truth? Given all the negativity about our product, unless we present it in the best possible manner, we’re not going to attract new clients.

We need to do more

Why isn’t just showing a comb running through hair and scalp enough to communicate this inherent drama? Because it’s been done before. Quite a bit. Nothing new or dramatic about it now. Time to move on.

OK, what’s next? Think along the lines of gradual hair replacement. That certainly demonstrated the inherent drama of the product, again, giving the prospective client permission to believe that this is something that doesn’t cover the scalp.

How could this “process” cover the scalp if the viewer saw a guy with just his crown and a little of the mid-scalp filled in with hair, right? After all, you could see the rest of his scalp.

Showing the hair gradually replaced sold a lot of hair. (I should know. I did the first gradual commercial twenty years ago.) But not a lot of studio owners sold gradual hair replacement. They could have replaced the hair gradually, like the commercial showed. There was no deception there: it was and is perfectly true. But most studio owners preferred not to do gradual applications. So, they sold the client off it and replaced his hair the conventional way. Nothing wrong with that either.

A starting point

Gradual hair replacement is a starting point for what I’m talking about. The industry needs to find more ways to demonstrate the inherent drama of non-surgical hair.

In a commercial for Folligraft, which I just finished for On Rite, we chose to present the product in a way as dramatic (but not all that different) as showing the hair replaced gradually. What we did was to show the hair replaced in various locations on a bald scalp, filling in the various areas until the entire scalp was covered with hair. In other words, we showed the client bald; then with a little hair in the crown; then with more hair in the crown and some hair in the mid-scalp; then with the crown completely filled in, some hair in the mid-scalp, the beginning of a hairline, etc., until the entire head of hair was replaced by the end of the sequence. Why did we do this?

Again, it all goes back to men not wanting to wear something on their heads. Just like with the gradual process, we were showing not a full head of hair, but hair lying right next to a bald portion of scalp. How does this sell hair?

Because we’re showing that the new hair lies perfectly flush with the scalp. There’s no interruption from say, the crown, where there is now hair, to just in front of it, which is still bald. Again, this gets away from the notion that we’re selling something that you wear on top of your head. Like a hat. Or a, you know, ahem, toupee.

Is this a lie? Let me ask you this: Can hair be applied randomly a little at a time? Of course, it can be. Could you in effect, take a hair graft, cut it apart, then apply it in small sections? Absolutely. Just like you can apply hair gradually from the back to the front. Is this the way studios will end up applying the product? Probably not. But they could if they wanted to. So, there’s no deception.

What we are doing at On Rite, and what the industry should be looking to do individually and collectively, is to find new ways to present our product to the public. This is called marketing. And today we’re in a marketing-driven business, whether we like it or not.

Our product is meant to alter perceptions

Now I know that there are some in the business who don’t like it. I know there are studio owners who say, “Hey, I don’t want to be less than straight with anybody.” But wait. Aren’t we in the business of altering perceptions? Isn’t it the purpose of the product that we sell to make people think our client has a full head of hair? Isn’t that separating perception from reality?

Of course, it is. We know that telling people that our product will alter perceptions is perfectly honest. We tell the client that if he has our product people will think it’s his real hair. And that’s true. It’s no less honest and no less ethical than getting that client into your studio by showing him different ways in which the hair can be legitimately and truthfully applied or styled or utilized. And that’s the truth.

Time to fight back

Don’t you ever get angry by how unfairly characterized our industry is? Don’t you ever wish you could set everyone straight about the real benefits of our product? Wouldn’t you like to fight back? Sure, you do. But you can’t do it by yourself. Your advertising has to do it for you.

There are so many unjust negatives about hair replacement that have to use marketing, real marketing, the sophisticated kind practiced by the DeBeers, Colgates and Miller Lites of then world. Why?

Because we have a big job to do: a major shift in consumer perception has got be made in order for us to sell our product.

That’s the hope for our industry, that’s the path to getting out of neutral and growing again. And that’s why I think that every studio owner and everyone else connected to the industry should be thinking along those lines.

We might not be able to control what others say about us. But we certainly can control what we say and how we present ourselves.

Editor’s note: This article first appeared in The National Hair Journal and is reproduced here both as creative advice as the industry becomes ever more visible on the web and as a caution to hair loss professionals to protect our integrity by pressing forward with advanced training and best practices.

Steve DiManni who passed away in 2011, was a close friend of The Hair Authority and one of the most insightful analysts in the hair management industry. A 24-year veteran of Madison Avenue and a 23-year veteran of the hair restoration industry, Steve won almost every major advertising industry creative award in existence, including Clios, Andys, and Effies. He was a Senior Vice President and Creative Director at a $100 million New York advertising agency and a long-time consultant to the OnRite Company.