News Headlines, Women & Beauty

Fight or Flee?

Fight or Flee?

By Michael Suba

When I was starting out in the business I would sometimes complain to my father about a troublesome client. His response was always, “That’s retail.” I found this to be neither helpful or supportive. And it really started to grate as it became his stock response (after he no longer had to deal with clients). But what he said was a fact.

Michael Suba

But what to do when a client is unhappy? I had a call several years ago from a colleague who was quite distressed by a client’s threats. The best advice I could give him was that he had to decide whether “to fight or to flee”. What is in your best interest? If you are going to fight, how are you going to win? If you are going to flee, how are you going to make sure that your flight is enough?

To be honest, I usually flee. On those occasions, I have fought all the way to court I have won, but its takes a lot of nervous energy that can be better used elsewhere. And let’s face it, we can’t usually afford the time or the fees.  But there are times when I will stand my ground. Maybe you’ve experienced something similar to what happened to me last spring.

I had a client, let’s call her Susie (not her real name), who would purchase toppers from me. When one of my stylists left me, and opened her own salon (not hair replacement), Susie started going to her to have her hair done. After a couple years, the inevitable happened and Susie came by to get a new topper. She said she wanted the same thing, so I pulled out her old order, took a deposit, and we were off.

When the unit came in, I was in for a surprise. This was an expensive item; 18-inch blonde virgin hair and it looked wonderful! But when Susie saw it, she immediately claimed that it was not the same as before. I showed her the color sample and the specs from her last order, but she insisted, showing me the hair in her tired four-year old topper, telling me that the new hair was too dark. I explained that her old hair had faded over the years, but Susie became very agitated and began crying, saying loudly that I was taking advantage of her…  and well, you have seen this sort of thing yourselves I am sure.

Anyway, I told Susie that I would order new hair to match her old topper and that I would show it to her before I made it into a system. She agreed, gave me a sample of the topper she was wearing, and I got to work. When her hair came in, I called her to come and see it. She said it was perfect and I sent it off to the factory to have it ventilated into the base she liked.  When it came back, I had it all washed and blown out ready for her arrival. I was talking to another client one day when my technician came into my consultation area. “She doesn’t like it,” she said. “What?” I asked, confused. “Who doesn’t like what?” “The client you remade that postiche for. She says it’s the wrong color.”

I made my way over to my client who starts in on me even before I arrive. All I am able to say is, “I’m sorry, Susie, but this is the color you signed off on.” But this cuts no ice. She persists and I repeat, “I don’t know what I can do. This is the color and the hair that you saw and approved.” Then she told me that, “In this light it looks different”” and before I could respond, she got up abruptly, stating, “Fine, I’ll take it! But you just lost a customer! “and made to leave.  I was not very sad about that. My receptionist got her card and the balance owing was paid. But as you probably guessed this was not the end.

Stage 1: We Will Sue You.

Later, when I was taking my wife out for the evening, I foolishly checked my phone.

Michael,

Once again, I find that you have bullied my sister, XXXXXXX, and provided her with a substandard product that was not at all what she ordered, and not in the least comparable to the last postiche she ordered from you. It seems you take some kine of joy out of scamming highly vulnerable clients.

I have reached out to my lawyer as I believe what you have done is committed a fraud against a cancer survivor. Can you please provide proof that the product you provided is indeed human hair, explain why it has been dyed yellow, and offer a written explanation of why you charged for a full postich while delivering the much shorter, much less full version of what you had promised?

I promise you that we will not go quiet into that good night. You should be ashamed. If you cannot deliver on the product, you need to refund my sister’s money That is the ethical thing to do – I guess my question is, can you do the ethical thing?

I look forward to your reply.  

xxxx

I do not respond to these things anymore. I let my lawyer do that. As business people, we need good professional advice from our lawyers and our accountants. So, I forwarded it to him. Fortunately for him, he was off proudly attending his daughter’s university graduation. I had to wait until he got back. So, I left it.

Stage 2: We Will Go to The Media.

Because I did not respond yet I received this the next day:

We have confirmed with another stylist that for the money XXXX’s pastiche should be considerably fuller and longer. Can you please respond to my earlier queries? If you are not going to make this right, I have no hesitation to reach out to the media – especially as you portray yourself in a way that is in high contrast to your actions. Please let us know how you will make this right. I have taken pictures of her original and the new pastiche you created. The difference is compelling. I await your response.

XXX

Sent from my iPhone

Yeah. Like many in this business over time you get to know people in “the media.” They come to you when they need a story, or when a presenter or an associate producer is going through chemo. All the major networks and news outlets know me, so it’s not scary.

I did call my publicist however (we also all need a publicist) and asked for advice which turned out to be the same as my wife’s; just pay her to go away. Her logic was that it was not worth the trouble, and I have to agree on that. But there was something there that I could not let go. I had been falsely accused. We have all had that happen to us, but I took exception to being bullied (at the same time as being labelled a bully). And this was even the level of extortion; ‘nice reputation, pay us and we’ll see nothing happens to it’. So, I rejected that advice. I was not going to flee.

Stage 3: Please Talk to Us.

So now it’s a matter of price. The accusations of are melting away. I felt some satisfaction about this; this sister of my ex client had looked at all the options she had threatened me with and they’d proven to be dead ends. Her bluster and bully tactics had come to nothing.  Normally I would have sympathized with anyone not happy with a product, but all that melted away with the shifting goalposts, insults, accusations and threats. Now they want to discuss terms of surrender. I got this the next day.

Subject: Response Requested

Good morning. I have now confirmed that the hair in the postiche is of high quality. However, it has also been confirmed that the cost of the produce greatly surpassed what was delivered.  Can you please have the courtesy to respond to my emails or reach out to my sister…

My Response the Next Day:

Dear Ms. XXX,

I have received and read your three e-mails.

I work very hard to provide good service and quality products to all of our clients. As a cancer survivor myself, I take a particular interest in ensuring that we deliver the best possible results to survivors, for many reasons, including the fact that many of them are vulnerable. Your accusations that I would take advantage of your sister or any other fellow survivor, and that I ”take some kine (sic) of joy out of scamming highly vulnerable clients” or “have committed a fraud” were upsetting and sickening.

However, I am going to give you the courtesy of the presumption that you do not know the entire story.

Your sister XXXXX was a client a number of years ago. She returned several months ago. She ordered a pastiche with long, high blonde hair. Despite care being taken to have it custom manufactured according to her instructions, she was unhappy with it. I agreed to retain it. It is a fine pastiche, but it is a custom hairpiece. The length and color will only suit a small number of people. It remains in our inventory. XXXX was not charged one penny for that piece.

I then ordered in hair that would actually be used in the replacement pastiche. XXX came to our salon, saw the hair and confirmed that she was happy with it, specifically the color. I then sent the hair to our manufacturer. When the piece arrived, XXXX came to pick it up. She was unhappy with the color. I reminded her that this was the hair she had seen and approved. She said something to the effect that she would just take it and that I had lost a customer. She paid and left.

I do not bully our clients and I did not bully XXXXX. Fortunately, members of my staff and another customer were present and can confirm that.

XXXXX knows as an experienced wearer of hairpieces that the hair can be colored or lightened. In ordinary circumstances, we could have done so, but in light of your first and second e-mails, I see no way to rebuild the trust that is required in our client relationship with XXXXX. (Your third e-mail pulls back from some of your earlier, inaccurate assertions, but the damage has been done.)

Yours very truly,

Michael Suba

I did receive another email from the sister saying it was not what she ordered and that I am still a bully and would I please try to color/style the system to her liking?  Some people never learn…

I am sure other managers might have dealt with this differently, and maybe there is a better solution out there. We are in business of helping people and we that’s what do, but we are in business ourselves too and sometimes that requires that we draw a line in the sand. 

I’ll tell you what I learned from this experience.  When I am unhappy with a product or service, my first approach is to be exceptionally nice. I don’t want to lose this reflex, no matter how challenging the situation. But I also learned how important it is to keep your records up to date. Record exactly what the client asked for to avoid the “I didn’t order this” syndrome like they were in a Chinese restaurant. I have even gone so far as to upgrade my security cameras. Although there is no sound recording, they are a great asset and help me document my clients’ preferences and requests.  I don’t get a lot of client complaints, but I have noticed that since I installed CCTV cameras, even those few complaints have dropped to almost nothing.

Hair is a very personal thing. It’s how we make our living. So, managing our clients’ expectations and reacting to their responses says as much about each of us as it does our clients. We all bend over backwards to serve our clients, but we also have to protect ourselves.

 

 

One thought on “Fight or Flee?”

  1. Sam Parkons says:

    Kudos.
    The way you are dealing with the things is great.