Blog
Is a Weak Brand Strategy Crippling Your Company
9 Things to Watch For
How strong is your company’s brand strategy? If they’re honest, many owners and business leaders would have to answer, “I’m not sure.” That’s because very few leaders understand brand, says Lindsay Pedersen. They (wrongly) believe it’s “squishy,” elusive, and superficial. The truth is, nothing is more powerful than a beloved brand—it’s what differentiates your business from everyone else’s and establishes the conditions for you to thrive.
“Product can be copied, patents expire, and features become obsolete,” says Pedersen, author of “Forging an Ironclad Brand: A Leader’s Guide. “What cannot be copied are relationships. What does not expire is the trust you earn by consistently solving a customer need. What never gets old is delight. A great brand strategy yields all these benefits. It creates loyal customers who stay with you.”
Pedersen says branding should be a company’s North Star. Every decision you make should be filtered through it. Forging an ironclad brand lets you occupy the single best position in the hearts and minds of your customers. When you pinpoint this optimal position, you’ll be able to create value, maximize scale, and lead with purpose. (See tipsheet below for Pedersen’s eight-step methodology.)
“Unfortunately, few leaders put in the work it takes to do this, and the result is a weak, anemic brand,” she says. “Dismissing brand results in a barren business, inhospitable for your customers, your employees, and all who benefit from knowing and experiencing the value you bring.”
Pedersen says the most value-creating brand strategies are the ones that meet these nine criteria:
BIG: Your brand promise must be big enough to matter. This is the space you own in your customer’s head. Make it a big space, a big promise. This will create value for both your customer and your business. By mattering to your customer, you fuel a business that matters.
EXAMPLE: Salesforce enables leaders to grow their businesses faster. This is a large and resonant promise for Salesforce’s target customer. A less big alternative might have been “track customer communication carefully” or “largest storage capacity among CRM solutions.” With its big promise, Salesforce is a beloved brand with a tremendous market capitalization.
NARROW: It must be narrow enough to own. While your brand positioning must be big enough to matter, it also must be narrow enough for you to dominate. Choose a positioning you uniquely can own—one where you are not just better, but you are different.
EXAMPLE: Dollar Shave Club chose a meaning narrow enough to own. They unabashedly targeted millennial males not loyal to the status quo way of buying shaving materials. With a subscription-based razor delivery model, Dollar Shave Club outflanked Gillette by not distributing through traditional retailers.
ASYMMETRICAL: It must use your lopsided advantage. Promise and deliver from your place of dramatically asymmetrical strength. (It’s asymmetrical because your edge comes not from being medium-good at a lot of things, but from being excellent at one thing.) Your positioning must pinpoint precisely what only you can bring to your customer that others cannot copy.
EXAMPLE: GORE-TEX has an asymmetrical advantage in waterproof fabrics. By inventing and patenting the technology for their fabric in 1969, they claimed the gold standard in waterproof fibers. As a result, GORE-TEX waterproof fabric is used in products manufactured by Patagonia, L.L. Bean, Oakley, Marmot, and The North Face (to name just a few).
EMPATHETIC: It must address a deeply relevant and meaningful need. Your positioning must genuinely have your customers’ interests at heart. Ironclad brands genuinely care about their customers and seek to serve them with authenticity.
EXAMPLE: Airbnb empathetically addresses a large and previously unserved desire. Based on a promise to “belong anywhere,” Airbnb marries two deep, human needs: the need to belong and the need to feel safe in parts of the world beyond our experience. The Airbnb promise is meaningful for guests, who get to experience a new place through the lens of a local, and hosts, who get to share their world with someone they’d otherwise never get to know.
OPTIMALLY DISTINCT: It must strike a balance between familiar and novel. Your brand positioning must be recognizable enough that your customer can easily grasp it, and yet new enough that it breaks through clutter and sparks intrigue. Familiarity gets you into the customer’s mind, while novelty attracts the customer’s attention.
EXAMPLE: Chobani yogurt blends the distinctness of Greek-style yogurt with the familiarity of mainstream American yogurt. Fage had made the mistake of being very different—an unintuitive-to-pronounce name (“Fah-jay”), large cartons, plain whole milk SKUs—and never broadly tapped Americans’ yogurt-eating. Mainstream American brands like Yoplait had become ho-hum, uninteresting—overly familiar. Chobani blended familiar (traditional American fruit flavors and single-size servings) with novel (Greek yogurt’s thick texture), growing it to be one of the largest in the yogurt category.
FUNCTIONAL AND EMOTIONAL: It must serve the customer on both functional and emotional levels. Your offering must be at the critical intersection of your customer’s heart and mind. If it’s only emotional, they might not believe it. If it’s only functional, they won’t bond with it or be loyal to it.
EXAMPLE: Etsy gets it just right by promising “something real from a real person”—an ideal intersection of functional and emotional. They bring the functional benefit of making it easy to find makers of what you need along with the emotional, soul-satisfying payoff of buying from a real artisan. It is functional enough to assuage the mind and emotional enough to capture the heart. In contrast, Microsoft Office is a brand that is overly functional—it is all about the product’s features and does nothing for your heart. And Jaguar is a brand that is too emotional—while the heart loves style and luxury, the mind can’t accept that it requires frequent repairs.

SHARP-EDGED: It must entail a single, sharp-edged promise. Your brand positioning must be simple and singular. It should be ridiculously clear to customers what you do and don’t promise. Focus on that specific benefit, with all you do and say supporting that single idea.
EXAMPLE: Let’s look at a few well-known car brands. When you say Volvo, I say safe. When you say Prius, I say fuel-efficient. When you say Jeep, I say fun. None of these brands overextend into being sporty, prestigious, or fast. It’s clear both what they do and what they don’t do. But when you say Buick, it doesn’t mean much. That’s a brand without sharp edges.
HAS TEETH: It must be demonstrably true. Your positioning must offer compelling, granular, concrete proof that it will deliver on its promise. It need not only be true, but demonstrably true. This helps customers believe it, trust it, and engage with it.
EXAMPLE: Plenty of insurance companies pitch a savings advantage. However, only Geico’s promise to save you money on car insurance is extremely specific, with numerical, relevant facts to back it up: “Fifteen minutes could save you 15 percent or more on car insurance.” Fifteen minutes is fast, but not so fast that it’s not believable. Fifteen percent is substantial but does not sound like an overpromise. The matching of “15 minutes” with “15 percent” makes the promise memorably specific.
DELIVERS: You must deliver on your brand promise across everything you do, from big to small, from new customer to loyal customer—consistently. You don’t just nail the letter of the promise, but the spirit of the promise.
EXAMPLE: Zappos promises world-class customer service, and they deliver on that consistently and across all dimensions. They hire people for their customer service ethic. Their processes are set up to reward creative, above-and-beyond ways to delight customers. They will get your merchandise to you in 24 hours. They provide free shipping both ways. Even their boxes are a treat to open. They deliver excellent customer service in spades.
“For a brand to meet these criteria, leaders must make difficult choices and trade-offs,” says Pedersen. “It can feel scary to decide so boldly and shine a spotlight on what you have selected. Yet choosing is what separates good leaders from great leaders, what separates flash-in-the-pan businesses from the ones that endure for generations.”
Eight Steps to Forging an Ironclad Brand
The Ironclad Method is the eight-step process Lindsay Pedersen uses to help businesses of all sizes—from solo-owned to publicly traded; from B2B to B2C; from stodgy, old-economy categories to disruptive, new-to-the-world innovations—build a powerful brand strategy.

“This method makes building your brand strategy a natural, energizing, fortifying discovery for your business,” says Pedersen, author of Forging an Ironclad Brand. “It is the crystallization and delivery of your business’s value to customers. You can and must gain this clarity.”
STEP 1: Orient. This is where you establish context. Whom do you serve and what are their alternatives for the problem you solve? In the first step of creating your brand strategy, you orient to your target customer and your competitive frame of reference. You define the most fertile place to lay your roots. The rest of your brand strategy will spring from these choices.
STEP 2: Listen. By getting into a listening mindset and preparing for and conducting customer research, you set up the richest building blocks for your brand strategy. Here is where you glean insights about the real human beings behind the concept of “target customer.” Your success depends largely on your mindset: You are seeking to learn, connect dots, and integrate—not simply record and then regurgitate.
STEP 3: Examine. Here you examine the insights you have collected and synthesize them into the Uncommon Denominator framework. The Uncommon Denominator is the intersection of what your customer wants, what you’re good at, and what your competition is not good at, or has chosen not to focus on. Drawing from this zone enables you to move from a brand that meets a need generically to a brand that meets a need uncommonly.
STEP 4: Ladder. Next you develop a ladder of benefits and reasons to believe that specify the promise your business makes, how you prove that promise, and what your customer ultimately enjoys as a result of experiencing that promise. This is perhaps the most critical step in the Ironclad Method: You distill your business’s value proposition into an argument that is at once grounded and aspirational. The ladder depicts the levels at which your business benefits your customer, from the functional and grounded to the emotional and transcendent.
STEP 5: Characterize. By pinpointing your character archetype and defining the personality and tonality of your business, you enable yourself and others to embody your brand consistently and genuinely. Human beings connect better with other human beings than they do with abstract entities. When you allow your business to show up with the characteristics of a person, you are working with, rather than against, the way people naturally bond.
STEP 6: Stage. In the sixth step, you will define each stage of your customer’s journey with your brand. Explicitly describing the stages enables you later to tailor your messages for a given customer in a given piece of communication, progressing those customers along in their journeys. All of this will connect the dots between your brand strategy and the deep customer engagement of an ironclad brand.
STEP 7: Activate creative. This step establishes the strategic directive, stripping out the extraneous and subjective before beginning the creative development process. When you activate creative, you put to use your ironclad brand strategy. The creative and messaging you develop—company name, logo, About Us page, packaging, photos for your website, Facebook ads, billboards, sales demos, and all the other things you do to communicate your brand for your audience—happen now.
STEP 8: Zoom out. Finally, you’ll zoom out to begin seeing brand in everything. You’ll do this through the lens of two classic frameworks that help leaders use brand as a complete strategic platform for growing with purpose. One is the 4 Ps—Product, Price, Place, and Promotion—a framework for marketing decision-making first proposed by Harvard Business School’s Jerome McCarthy in 1960, and later popularized by Philip Kotler of the Kellogg School of Management. The other framework is the 3 Ds that I learned from former Clorox Company CEO Don Knauss—Desire, Decide, and Delight—which are the three “moments of truth” that occur with your target customer.
“Once you’ve created your brand strategy methodically, thoroughly, and honestly, it should guide you at your highest level,” says Pedersen. “Let it not be merely for marketing tactics, pricing, or your next messaging campaign, but, rather, let it infuse everything. Let it not be just for customers or just for employees; rather, let it inspire everyone.”
About the Author: Lindsay Pedersen is the author of Forging an Ironclad Brand: A Leader’s Guide. She is a brand strategist, board advisor, coach, speaker, and teacher known for her scientific, growth-oriented approach to brand building. She developed the Ironclad Method for value-creating brands while working with billion-dollar businesses like Starbucks, Clorox, Zulily, T-Mobile, and IMDb, as well as many burgeoning start-ups. Lindsay lives in Seattle with her husband and two children. For more information, please visit www.ironcladbrandstrategy.com.
About the Book: Forging an Ironclad Brand: A Leader’s Guide (Lioncrest Publishing, April 2019, ISBN: 978-1-544-51386-7, $27.99) is available at bookstores nationwide and from major online booksellers.